Mainstream media pundits, economists, and journalists love to lump gold in with other commodities. They put it in the same category as oil, copper, wheat, natural gas, and other things that come out of the ground. But while gold is in fact a metal you must dig up, it’s a mistake to call it “just another commodity.” Gold’s long history and even recent price performance shows that it is anything but “just another commodity.” Gold is a unique financial asset and a superior safe-haven asset to own in times of financial duress.
Gold Compared to Other Commodities
Since the beginning of 2016, the market has demonstrated that gold is a unique asset we should approach differently than other commodities. Here is a chart comparing the price of gold against major US domestic indices since the beginning of the year.
Regardless of what you may think is behind the downward pressure on stock prices; the European banking system, China’s capitulating stock market and massive capital outflows, or the creeping realization that Janet Yellen and other central bankers cannot effectively manage the economy, the big picture is clear. In times of financial duress, global capital flows to gold.
But what about other commodities? Does capital flow into oil or livestock during times of financial uncertainty and risk? They are, after all, “hard assets” and not paper claims to an asset. Shouldn’t they behave in the same way as gold? Here is a chart comparing gold to popular commodities over the same time period.
This chart shows the relative price performance of gold against copper, oil, natural gas, and livestock. The middle of last year serves as the midpoint on the chart. At that time, all of these commodities began to trend decisively lower – except for gold. Oil led the charge with a breathtaking 60%-plus decline in price. Only recently has it shown signs of cooling off. But the damage has already been done for companies that were betting on a higher price.
Though more gradual, copper’s performance looks just as painful.
Gold however, represented by the red line, proved resilient, and just recently started its double digit price ascension from $1060 per ounce all the way up to as high as $1250 per ounce. That represents a 17% move in less than two months.
There is an obvious difference between gold and other commodities, and the magnitude of difference is noteworthy. The following chart puts this into perspective.
There is not a single commodity listed above that falls within a 20% range of gold’s price performance over the past year.
The difference between gold and these other commodities should be obvious. Gold historically attracts capital in ways that other commodities do not. This is especially true during times of financial uncertainty, increased perceived risk, and fears around entering a prolonged period of economic recession or depression.
Drilling Deeper: Gold and Oil
Many investors like to group all “hard assets,” or commodities, together, thinking they must all perform the same way in most scenarios. This just ain’t so. Let’s drill deeper to find out why by comparing oil and gold.
First, oil presents serious storage issues compared to gold.
Secondly, the price of oil is very sensitive to potential changes in the above ground supply, which is pretty limited. That is not the case with gold. A stable supply of gold exists above ground flowing to whomever wants it most. To put it another way, the stocks to flow ratio for gold is measured in decades, whereas for oil, it’s measured in months.
Finally, simply reviewing the price history for both shows that oil is much more volatile than gold. Volatility is not something you would expect to see, or desire, in a “safe haven” or “hard asset.”
Gold is not just another commodity or hard asset. It is the superior safe haven financial asset in a world where both commodities and financial assets are becoming increasingly risky.
A version of this article was originally published here.